Black Church, School, and Community Organizing

C-4148 final image sequence.pdf

In May 1865, with the war having recently drawn to a close, a group of Black Baltimoreans attempted to organize a public meeting “for the purpos of procuring money to convey the body of a lady to Culpeper Count House Va.” The organizers had invited Black Maryland’s most famous son, Frederick Douglass, to speak and hoped to rent the auditorium of the “Maryland Institute” (presumably the Maryland Institute for the Promotion of the Mechanic Arts on Market Place) or another similarly-sized venue for the event. Despite having been able to rent such spaces in the past, however, the organizers had been denied by the boards of managers of two venues on the grounds that “the Colord ordnian [audience] will geather on the street in front of the Halls & stop the way of the street.”

In the wake of these refusals, B. R. Hawley, one of the event organizers, wrote to Secretary of War Edwin M. Stanton requesting his intervention in the dispute. In his letter, Hawley rejected the excuses given by the managers of the venues and framed the refusals as an attack on the rights of Black Baltimoreans. Far from being motivated by concerns about crowding in the streets, Hawley argued, the managers had refused to rent their venues due to “predidess [prejudice] against the Colord men. or [in] other Words a gainst the Colord nattion.” Such conduct was especially galling in light of the contributions Black Baltimoreans had made to the war effort, Hawley suggested. “[T]he Colord men of this city have Assiste[d] in all the war and they aught to Have the wright of the Hall for sutch a case,” he told Stanton. Ultimately, Hawley believed, the dispute came down to which side had the superior right. “[T]the bord [of managers] may have a wright of refusing the Colord Class,” he admitted, but, more importantly, “the Colord Have a wright to the Hall as long as thay can pay for it.”

Hawley’s letter and the dispute it described speak to the contradictory experiences of Black community organizers and institutions in Civil War Maryland. For many Black Marylanders, war, emancipation, and military service were profoundly radicalizing and empowering experiences. The balance of power seemed to have shifted in Maryland, with Maryland enslavers forced onto the defensive and new potential allies in the form of the Federal authorities present in the state. In that context, enslaved and free Black Marylanders felt confident enough to bring their community institutions out of the shadows and into the light of day. From the Eastern Shore to the Piedmont, Black Marylanders seized the opportunity to establish new churches, seek fresh funding for their schools, and organize public gatherings of a newly-assertive political community. 

Even in the midst of this efflorescence of organizing, however, Black Marylanders continued to encounter formidable opposition. Maryland’s enslavers and Confederate sympathizers may have been on the back foot, but they were still more than willing to use both the state’s slavery-era laws and the threat of extra-judicial violence to strangle emerging Black public institutions. And if federal authorities sometimes acted as a bulwark against the slaveholding reaction, they often proved themselves to be at best uncertain and inconsistent allies of Black Marylanders. 

The documents in this exhibit illustrate both sides of this contradictory process. They show how the experiences of the war years encouraged Black organizers like B. R. Hawley to demand the right to take and hold public space and allowed Black preachers like Benjman Howard to return home after a period of forced exile. But these documents also depict rebel sympathizers organizing a wave of church burnings and other terrorist activities on the Eastern Shore and Black passengers being forced to ride in the stifling confines of the smoking car on the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad. Taken together, the documents in this collection reveal both the liberatory promise of Black community organizing and the daunting institutional and social obstacles it confronted in Civil War Maryland.

Mapping Freedom's Struggle

The interactive map below charts the attempts of Black Marylanders to destroy slavery. Where documents engage multiple areas, we have placed a point for each on the map. You can click on each point for a summary and transcription of the related document, click through to view a particular document in greater detail, or zoom in or out for different vantage points of freedom's struggle.

A-9745 final image sequence.pdf

Explore Black Church, School, and Community Organizing

Black preacher Benjman Howard began “prech[ing] In the M E church” in Baltimore sometime before 1855. He “was travling In Anaplaus Marland In may 1855,” he reported to the Freedmen’s Bureau, when he met Samuel E. Duvall, a wealthy enslaver and planter, who “came and tuck me home to his house 3 miles and A haff from Amaplas.” There, Duvall and his wife “prasuaded me to Leve Baltimore and he wood give me graund to Bild A house on In Anaplas Neck.” 

Howard recalled that “In July 1857 I movd from Baltimore to Anaplas  In my one [own] house I thair Livd comfortable fore 3 yeairs,” but the comfort was short-lived. “In the year 1861,” he explained, “the atharateys starped mee from preching  And in Auguest 1862 I was A Rested and put in Prison fore preching then my house was sarched” by the Duvalls and his papers destroyed. Secession, it appears, had fundamentally altered their relationship to the Black preacher. 

Howard’s work as a Black minister in Civil War Maryland not only led to suspicion, but incarceration, apprenticeship, and banishment for the 68-year-old minister. “I Lade in prison an till febury the 3th 1863,” he testified, and “was tackon to the court house and thair sold out fore 15 yeairs fore Biding me not to cross the Lines of marland.”

Howard’s devastating experiences reveal the difficulty in adequately describing Black politics in Maryland, a difficulty intentionally produced by the state itself. Howard encountered a landscape of formal, institutional exclusion in Maryland. The restrictions on Black preaching, for example, were passed in the aftermath of the Nat Turner Rebellion when enslavers and their allies came to understand the revolutionary potential of these spaces. Despite being formally free, Howard was in fact anything but, and lost his legal freedom because of white surveillance and criminalization of Black religious activities, assemblies, and organizing.

His careful account of the details of his case, including witnesses like Rev. John H. Brice—a free Black carpenter who, by 1870, had been ordained as a minister in the Methodist Episcopal Church—appears to have been ignored by the Freedmen’s Bureau, who took no action in his case. Nonetheless, Howard’s story reveals the importance of these institutions to a newly-assertive Black political landscape following emancipation. As former enslavers and their allies well understood, these spaces carried with them substantial liberatory potential. 

You can read the letters of Howard and Hawley, along with those of other Black organizers, agitators, and communities, in the section that follows.

A Black clergyman described having been arrested and sold out of the state for preaching.

A-9745 final image sequence.pdf
In January 1866, Benjman Howard, a Black clergyman, described his antebellum career as a preacher in Annapolis and his purchase of a home there in 1857. In 1862, however, Howard had been arrested for preaching and held in jail until, in February 1863, he was sold out of the state and forbidden from returning to Maryland.

A Black surgeon complained about the discrimination his wife endured on the segregated train from Baltimore to Washington, D.C.

C-4147 - Alexander Augusta protesting segregated seating on Baltimore line for wife-3-7.pdf
Black surgeon Alexander T. Augusta wrote to the commander of the Middle Department to complain about the treatment his wife and another Black woman had experienced on the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad. The railroad, August alleged, charged Black passengers the same fare as whites but required them to travel in a car filled with tobacco smoke. “It makes no difference how respectable a colored lady may be; how disagreable smoking may be to her; or how ill she might be, the employees about the depot will not permit her to enter another car, and should she by chance get into another and is found there, she is rudely thrust out,” Augusta noted.

Black residents of Baltimore were prevented from renting a concert hall to host a lecture by Frederick Douglass.

C-4148 final image sequence.pdf
In May 1865, B.R. Hawley, a Black resident of Baltimore, wrote to Secretary of War Edwin M. Stanton to complain that that the Black people of the city had been unable to rent either the Maryland Institute Hall or the Templars Hall for a meeting at which the announced speaker was Frederick Douglass. The requests to rent the venues had been refused on the grounds that Black Baltimoreans would gather in the street in front of the halls. Hawley believed the real reason was prejudice against Black residents of Baltimore and "against the colored nattion."

A group of Black clergymen requested that the African Methodist Episcopal Church be granted control of churches used by Black congregations in the South.

l-53 final image sequence.pdf
In the summer of 1864, a group of Black clergymen wrote to Secretary of War Edwin M. Stanton in response to his order authorizing the Methodist Episcopal Church, North, to take possession of all Southern Methodist Churches. The men informed Stanton of the existence of A.M.E. church, the strength of its membership and ministers, and the readiness of the A.M.E. to assume control of the spiritual direction of Black Southerners. “The aforementioned order virtually excludes us from a vast field of Christian labor among our brethren, whom we have long prayed to meet, and organize,” the Black clergymen told Stanton.

On Maryland’s Eastern Shore, a Black church was burned by Confederate sympathizers.

K-4 -- white postmaster on church burnings final image sequence.pdf
In November 1864, a white postmaster on the Eastern Shore wrote to the commander of the Middle Department regarding the burning of the Black Methodist Episcopal Church in Worcester County. According to the postmaster, the incident was just one of many such attacks on Black Marylanders and other Unionists.

When arsonists burned down Black churches on the Eastern Shore, Army officers levied a tax on local rebel sympathizers to pay to rebuild them.

C-8877 final image sequence.pdf
In late 1864, a Union army officer on the Eastern Shore of Maryland recommended to his superiors that the property of local rebel sympathizers be taxed to pay for repairs to Black churches that had been damaged by arsonists. The officer’s idea was accepted and orders issued for a levy on the property of disloyal and "disaffected" citizens to rebuild the damaged churches.

An order of Black nuns petitioned the Freedmen’s Bureau for financial support for their school and orphanage.

A-9634 final image sequence.pdf
In October 1867, the Oblate Sisters of Providence, a Baltimore order of Black nuns, wrote to William H. Day, the Freedmen’s Bureau superintendent of schools, asking for financial assistance for the school and orphanage that they ran. Their letter gave a history of the school, which the nuns had established for the education of Black children of all denominations.
Black Church, School, and Community Organizing